AI-generated imageA building can participate in a lights-out program for years and still need its glass changed. McCormick Place’s Lakeside Center in Chicago did both: its operator describes a long-running lighting program followed by a window retrofit in 2024. That history deserves another look while New York considers extending bird-friendly requirements to existing buildings. The question is when owners should have to address a dangerous surface that is already standing. McCormick Place, New York City Council
New York’s November 2020 implementation notice set a boundary. From January 10, 2021, new buildings and alterations replacing all of a building’s exterior glazing had to meet bird-friendly design requirements. Alterations replacing only part of that glazing were excluded. That was a way to change the next construction project; it did not require every existing window to be treated at once. Department of Buildings notice
The council’s current file for Introduction 140, including its proposed amended text, would extend the requirement to replacement of any exterior glazing and set a January 1, 2030 compliance date for existing business, mercantile and residential buildings, with an exception for detached one- and two-family dwellings. The file remained in committee when checked for this article. A proposal has no completed buildings to show for itself. It does, however, put the choice of leaving older glass untouched before the city. Council file and proposed text
In January 2025, McCormick Place’s operator, the Metropolitan Pier and Exposition Authority, announced that recorded collisions during the 2024 fall migration had dropped by more than 95% after bird-safe film was installed the previous summer. The film adds a visible pattern of dots to the glass. The release does not identify the comparison year or provide the underlying collision totals. It also describes other changes: closing curtains and blinds overnight where possible, switching off nonessential exterior lights and a much longer history of turning off interior lights when the building was unoccupied. Those facts support crediting a program of changes. They do not establish a 95% effect for film alone. Operator’s announcement
In its 2021 account of research at McCormick Place, the Field Museum described a statistical model combining lighting and collision records with weather, migration and seasonal conditions. The researchers investigated the relationship while accounting for those other factors. This article relies on the museum’s account; the paper’s full text was unavailable through the repository checked. Neither that analysis nor the later retrofit announcement supplies a head-to-head trial of switching lights off against treating glass. Field Museum
A national park shows why making the two measures compete would miss part of the problem. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, which also assisted McCormick Place, describes the Painted Desert Community Complex at Petrified Forest National Park as already turning its lights off at night. Its courtyard glass still presented a daytime hazard. The park applied visible film while awaiting a longer-term replacement with etched glass. The agency gives no quantified effect for that intervention; the example identifies a hazard left after the lights go out. Fish and Wildlife Service
The work is followed by people who encounter the injuries. Chicago Bird Collision Monitors describes volunteers recovering birds in the early mornings during migration, helping the injured and recording deaths. Its advocacy supports both safer lighting and building design. Those are the people whose observations a maintenance program should keep using after the installers leave. Chicago Bird Collision Monitors
At an MPEA board meeting in September 2024, the published minutes record the group’s director, Annette Prince, welcoming the window improvements and raising plans for further light reduction during migration. A facility official replied that curtains stayed closed unless an event requested otherwise. The exchange records a practical issue that a completed installation cannot settle: who controls the nightly operation afterward. The account is a summary of remarks in the authority’s minutes. September 24 meeting, public comment
Retrofitting is work, and a citywide requirement needs people able to do it. New York’s proposed amended text includes a glazier apprenticeship workforce program alongside the expanded building duties. Neither that provision nor one convention center establishes how much each other owner should spend, or which treatment fits every building. They are reasons to design a workable obligation with technical assessment, an implementation schedule and trained installers. Proposed amended text
Cities should make collision prevention part of maintaining existing buildings. Start with recorded hazards, require an owner’s plan for the glass and lighting, and keep monitoring after the changes. A treatment should earn its continued use through what happens at the building, without borrowing a percentage from a different site. New York’s pending measure offers one route for extending responsibility; Chicago and the national park show why that responsibility has something concrete to work on.
A bird cannot choose the date on which a building replaces its windows. Leaving prevention until that date makes the construction schedule decide how long a known danger remains. McCormick Place’s dots belong in a broader account of building care—alongside the switches, the curtains and the people who return to find out what happened overnight.
Sources
Links in the text lead to the original material the journalist used.
- Operator’s announcement mccormickplace.com
- Proposed amended text legistar.council.nyc.gov
- Department of Buildings notice nyc.gov
- Field Museum fieldmuseum.org
- Fish and Wildlife Service fws.gov
- Chicago Bird Collision Monitors birdmonitors.net
- September 24 meeting, public comment mpea.com
Revision history
No revisions.
Discussion
Questions, counter-arguments and sourced corrections are welcome. Comment policy
Loading comments…