AI-generated imageThree days ago this publication reported that Nvidia’s board had accepted Jensen Huang’s resignation before the inquiry it had opened into him reached any public conclusion. Since then the inquiry has picked up a second job. On Saturday two investment firms asked the board to keep open the possibility that Huang comes back.
The sequence so far is short. On November 8 the board said it was opening an independent investigation after “recent reporting” that Huang, Nvidia’s founder and chief executive, had been the target of a foreign intelligence effort. Independent directors, with outside counsel, would oversee it; the board said it had no reason to believe national security or company secrets were compromised, and that it had confidence in Huang. On November 10 the independent directors retained Joon H. Kim, a former acting U.S. attorney in Manhattan, and the law firm Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen & Katz, according to The Next Web. On November 11 the board accepted Huang’s resignation as president, chief executive and director, “effective immediately,” according to the company’s filing. The announcement the next day named Colette Kress, the finance chief, interim chief executive, made Harvey C. Jones the board’s first-ever chair, and said the board would look at internal and external candidates for a permanent leader. Neither document mentioned the inquiry.
On November 13 NBC News, citing unnamed sources, reported that the independent directors “plan to continue investigating” Huang despite his resignation. The report gave no reason, and the board statement and resignation filings I reviewed say nothing about whether the inquiry goes on. On November 14 CNBC published a letter from Brad Gerstner of Altimeter Capital and Gavin Baker of Atreides Management, whose firms reported holding about $2.1 billion of Nvidia stock between them as of June 30. They asked for a slow and deliberate process on Nvidia’s future leadership, one that weighs options including “the potential return of Jensen Huang.” Huang, they wrote, deserves a process without “any needless rush to replace him before all the facts are known.” The letter did not ask for his immediate reinstatement. CNBC reported no response from Nvidia.
The letter’s best phrase is that last one. Not before all the facts are known is a sound rule for replacing a founder. It is just as sound a rule for restoring one, and the letter is not the only party that could break it. Once a return is a live option, every week the inquiry runs is a week in which the company Huang built, and investors who value him, are waiting on it. NBC put Nvidia’s loss in market value during the week of the resignation at $585 billion. An inquiry into a founder whose name moves the share price is unlikely, I expect, to keep its own pace for long: the market will press for an answer, and the answer that can be given fastest is the one that lets the old arrangement resume.
The pressure is not peculiar to Nvidia. The closest recent case is OpenAI. In November 2023 its board fired Sam Altman; within days he was back as chief executive. A review by the law firm WilmerHale followed. According to Fortune, which reported the summary OpenAI published in March 2024, the firm conducted dozens of interviews and reviewed 30,000 documents. The summary blamed a breakdown in trust between the old board and Altman, found that the board had acted within its discretion, and concluded that “his conduct did not mandate removal.” Altman rejoined the board. The review may well have been right, and nothing in the summary suggests otherwise. But by the time it reported, the decision it could have informed had already been made, and the public saw only a summary of why.
Uber in 2017 shows the other order. Eric Holder’s firm, Covington & Burling, had been hired to examine Uber’s workplace culture after a former employee’s sexual harassment allegations. On June 13 that year, the AP reported, Uber published Holder’s recommendations—13 pages, all adopted unanimously by its board—and kept the full report private “to protect the privacy of those filing complaints.” Holder recommended moving some of Travis Kalanick’s responsibilities to other executives, and Kalanick took a leave of absence of no set length. The findings arrived first, and the leadership arrangement was built around them. The company also found a way to say what its inquiry had concluded without exposing the people who had spoken to it.
Nvidia’s inquiry faces real limits on what it can publish. It began with reports of foreign intelligence targeting and may touch material that cannot be released, and Huang’s family life is no shareholder’s business. Neither limit requires silence about the procedure. The board can say now, without revealing a single finding, which questions the inquiry has been asked to answer, who oversees it now that the board has a chair, and on what date it will next say where things stand. That last request is different from a deadline. Forcing an inquiry to finish by a set date would tie it to the calendar in another way; a date for the next account only keeps it in view.
The board should also commit to one thing about order: no permanent decision on who runs Nvidia—Huang, Kress or anyone else—before the inquiry’s conclusions have been reported, at least in the form Uber used. There is a cost. Nvidia’s own announcement says Kress will hold the finance job as well as the chief executive’s until a successor is named, and an interim period stretched by an inquiry is a real burden on a company that size. Gerstner and Baker are right that rushing is the danger. They have only named one direction of it.
Huang may have earned the deliberate process his backers ask for. A deliberate process has a sequence, and on November 8 the board set its first step by opening the inquiry. If he is to come back, the findings have to come out first, or his return will rest on the same thing his departure did: a decision taken before anyone outside the boardroom knew why.
Sources
Links in the text lead to the original material the journalist used.
- said nvidianews.nvidia.com
- according to The Next Web thenextweb.com
- filing sec.gov
- announcement sec.gov
- reported nbcnews.com
- CNBC cnbc.com
- Fortune fortune.com
- AP reported katv.com
Revision history
No revisions.
Discussion
Questions, counter-arguments and sourced corrections are welcome. Comment policy
Loading comments…